This article contains spoilers for The Secret History of Twin Peaks.
The Secret History of Twin Peaks is the third Twin Peaks novel, written by Mark Frost. It was released on October 18, 2016. The book is presented as a dossier, compiled by an unknown archivist, with annotations from FBI Special Agent "TP," who has been assigned to discover the archivist's identity.
The book is organized as a dossier with annotations by Special Agent "TP", who has been assigned by Deputy Director Gordon Cole to discover the identity of the person who compiled the dossier, referred to as the Archivist.
The dossier contains documents pertaining to the town of Twin Peaks and its inhabitants, particularly Douglas Milford. Milford was the town drunk until he drifted away from Twin Peaks and eventually joined the Air Force. During his time in the Air Force, he ended up in Roswell, New Mexico, where he was present for the alleged UFO crash. Following this incident, he was assigned to investigations pertaining to UFO sightings and was eventually put on Project Blue Book.
The Archivist revealed his identity as Major Garland Briggs, who Milford hand-picked as his successor. The dossier ended with a 'MAYDAY' message from Briggs on March 28, 1989, and Agent "TP" sent her findings to her superiors, signing her name as Tamara Preston.
Using 3D glasses on certain illustrations reveal interesting details with, as Dr. Jacoby says in the book, Red suppressing the logical and Blue suppressing the intuitive.
- On another picture of an Owl, Red shows the Freemasonry's all-seeing eye (the Great Sign) within the representation of the fifth triangular number figure (instead of a common triangle). Blue shows only an owl, the representation of the Illuminati.
- On a picture of an Owl, Red shows the face of a stereotypical alien while Blue only shows an Owl.
- On the cover of Jacoby's book, The Eye of God, Red removes the subtitle "Sacred Psychology in the Aboriginal Mind" and the brand logo, leaving only the title followed by Dr. Lawrence Jacoby'sname and also simplifies the cover picture to a dot inside a square inside another square. Blue changes nothing.
- The preface of Jacoby's book: Red removes the name of those giving a favorable review of the book and half of Jacoby's picture. Blue removes the other half of Jacoby's picture.
- On the picture of Leland and BOB, Red removes BOB. Blue changes nothing.
- On Norma's postcard to her parents, Red obscures (but does not completely eliminate) all her text, including the name and address of her parents ("Lindstrom rather than "Blackburn"), and parts of the anachronistic "First Man On The Moon" stamp. Blue eliminates the "Post Card" label and lines (though not completely the stamp or postmark).
- Red removes all the marginal notes from "TP", including her verification of the facts and the further conclusions she draws—as well as her identification as "Tamara Preston".
Secret messages or odditiesEdit
- On the picture of the Bookhouse Boys favorite books numbered from 1 to 11 by the Archivist using "I" instead of "1" like everywhere else he typed this number in his sections of the dossier. The Archivist also notes on this page that “Good literature is a mirror through which we see ourselves more clearly…”.
This means that the Archivist might be aware of what happened to Cooper.
- Milford's Buick's receipt was probably typed with the Archivist's typewriter as indicated lack of the numeral "1" which is replaced with an "I". It might be to indicate that Milford is not the Man in Black driving a black Buick sedan in the 1940's. To support that, Milford states in his diary after his visit of a military facility by Nixon, that his car was parked next to a black sedan. Furthermore, this receipt is not validated by one of TP's verifications.
- The Ghostwood Bill of Sale was similarly likely forged by the Archivist. It might be to indicate that Ghostwood was not actually sold. Furthermore, this document is not validated by one of TP's verifications.
- Agent Preston doesn't end at least one of her anotation with "TP": annotation number 2 of section 7 of NOTABLE FAMILIES. This note is the one detailing what happened to Catherine and the Mill after the bank explosion.
Differences between versionsEdit
The audiobook companion has at least two images different from other versions of the novel:
- The picture of the Bookhouse books puts then name of the appropriate member under each of the 11 volumes, instead of a numbering going from "I" to "II" above them.
- The cover of The Eye of God by Dr. Jacoby has a different illustration which is not affected by the use of 3D Glasses.
The book contains various alleged continuity errors with the series. Indeed, author Mark Frost purposefully decided for the book to be a dossier comprised of a set of documents authored by various people, in which the facts presented could be in-universe errors made by these characters, even purposefully putting typos or statements that seem untrue. His reasoning being that actual historical documents are filled with inaccuracies.
Within the book alone Edit
- Milford's enlistment form is to the US Air Force in 1941 while the book itself also states that he enlisted to the US Army Air Corps and that it did not become the USAF until 1947.
- The Archivist talks about Milford with contempt when recounting the events of the 1940's. But starting on the page where he begins to talk about himself with the first person, as noted by TP, he talks about Milford fondly.
- This shift in tone and behavior regarding Milford might indicate a change of Archivist.
- The archivist's "faithful Corona" does not have a * key even though he typed this symbol several times, including under this very picture. Other symbols such as the # and “ ” marks are also not on the depicted corona, which appears to be a 1939 Corona Standard with a German QWERTZ keyboard. While Corona has produced QWERTZ typewriters, those in the Standard series are uncommon if they ever even existed.
- The Archivist constantly uses upper case i "I" every time he should use "1", indicating that his typewriter does not have this key although the common real world usage is to use lower case l "l" since it is the exact same symbol. The archivist reveals himself to be Briggs and then put the picture of his typewriter which has the "1" key and starting on the next page with the transcript of his discussion with Milford, he uses "1" instead of any substitution.
- It may be to indicate a change of Archivist. This follows the shift in style noted before.
- States that Robert Jacoby died in 1969 before Milford bought the Twin Peaks Gazette and changed its name into the Twin Peaks Post. But many articles from Robert were written in the Post later and he was stated to have died again on November 19, 1986.
- It probably is a typo, with Milford buying the Gazette following the death of Richard Jacoby instead of his son Robert's "first death".
- Jacoby has moved to Hawaii on March 19 but wrote a report on Ben's Civil War on March 22 at Calhoun Memorial Hospital.
- Robert Jacoby notes on page 316 that he "first met [The Log Lady] in third grade ... And [he] was seated behind her." On page 320, his funeral cards indicate he was born in May 1931. This would make him a 16 year old 3rd grader since the Log Lady was in third grade in 1947 according to the "Three Students Vanish" entry beginning on page 142.
- Douglas Milford's middle name is given as "James" in his Roswell interview, while his obituary says "Raymond."
- He might have multiple middle names or one of them could just be a nickname.
- Milford's enlistment form from 1941 states that he has no distinctive marks. In 1985, he reveals a three triangle marking on his forearm to Major Briggs, dating back from his scoutmaster youth in Ghostwood Forest before his enlistment as noted by TP.
- The Archivist's last entry is from March 28, 1989, yet the dossier contains the dying letter of Hank written three years later and Harry's letter which was apparently written after Cooper left town. He also wrote that Catherine became a recluse after the bank explosion which occurred on the very same day and that Lana got out of Twin Peaks six months later to get remarried.
- This might indicate that the Archivist worked on earlier sections after writing this last entry. To support it, on her last entry, TP mentions "the other data" that she did not yet see.
- Benjamin Horne is stated to have been the student manager for the Twin Peaks High School football team in 1968. However, his birth date is later given as August 4, 1940, which would have made him 27 or 28 years old, a decade older than most high school seniors.
With the real world Edit
- It can also be noted that one of the books from the picture of the Bookhouse Boys favorite tomes, The Boys of Summer, is an edition from 2006 meaning that the picture can not be from when the dossier was made. Indeed, the Harper Perennial 'olive' logo did not exist before 2005.
- It might be done on purpose to indicate that the Archivist retroactively took the picture to include the secret message: "Fear the Double"/"Cooper"
- The Hollywood postcard from Norma to her parents is dated April 17, 1969, while its FIRST MAN ON THE MOON stamp was later issued on September 9, 1969. Not verified by TP.
- Norma also wrote that the Tonight Show's guests that day were Sammy Davis Jr. and Victor Buono. In real life, the guests actually were Victor Buono and Peggy Lee (aka Norma Egstrom). Not verified by TP.
- Douglas Milford's enlistment form in the United States Air Force is from December 1941, although the archivist states that it was the Army Air Corps. But in the real world, it was actually the Army Air Forces from June 1941 to 1947.
With the rest of the franchise Edit
With the TV series and movies Edit
- The Archivist states Pete Martell played checkers, not chess. In the series, Pete assists Agent Cooper in his chess match with Windom Earle.
- Though, the Archivist was speaking figuratively, stating just after it that Catherine was "only playing hardball."
- In the book, Norma's mother is stated to be named Ilsa and that she died in 1984, five years before the show takes place. However, in the show, her mother is shown to be Vivian Smythe Niles, who is clearly alive and well.
- Upon being asked about this error on Twitter, Mark Frost replied, "All will be revealed in time," suggesting not only is Frost aware of this inconsistency but intentionally put it in the book.
- Nadine's maiden name is stated in the book to be "Gertz", while Episode 17 states that it is "Butler".
- It could be explained by "Gertz" and/or "Butler" actually being a middle name.
- In the book, Nadine's birthdate is given as January 25, 1950, which would make her 39 years old in the February–March 1989 setting of the original show. But the show states her age to be 35.
- Dr. Jacoby states that Laura turned 18 on the day she began consulting him when the show explicitly states her to have died at 17.
- It might be because Laura lied to him so that he was not legally obliged to inform her parents.
- Details of Ed and Nadine's relationship are different between the show and book. In the show, Ed and Nadine were married the spring after high school after Norma cheated on Ed with Hank. During their honeymoon, he accidentally shot out Nadine's eye with a buckshot that ricocheted off of a rock. The book states that Ed and Norma's relationship crumbled while Ed was in Vietnam and Hank intercepted letters he had sent to her, then Ed and Nadine fell in love after meeting at his gas station and that Nadine's eye was shot out during a hunting trip they took with Harry S. Truman.
- The book states that Douglas Milford changed the name of the Twin Peaks Gazette to the Twin Peaks Post prior to when the series takes place although characters still call it the Gazette.
- However, the newspaper props seen episodes 18, 23 and 26 bear "The Twin Peaks Post," indicating that it was officially renamed the Post but still commonly referred to as the Gazette.
- Ben is stated to have surrendered at Appomattox during his Civil War reenactment following Jacoby's advice to get to the truth. In the show, Jacoby is the one who surrendered at Appomattox wanting for Ben reverse his emotional center.
- The reconciliation between Ben and Audrey is not apparent in the book, due to a bitter note allegedly left by Audrey before she went to the bank. The note also indicates that Ben planned on proceeding with the Ghostwood plans, despite his campaign against it by the end of the show and the fact that it was in Catherine Martell's hands at this point.
- This might be a consequence of changing the course of Ben's Civil War.
- In the pilot set in February 1989, Harry S. Truman states Andrew Packard's "death" to have taken place "last year," which would presumably mean 1988. However, the book and the Access Guide state that it occurred on September 27, 1987.
- In episode 1, Harry now claims it to be "one year and a half" which mean that Harry could have simply misspoken since February is still relatively early in a given year.
- The Twin Peaks Post article mentions Margaret's Log being Douglas Fir, even though it has always been stated as Ponderosa Pine, including in the Access Guide.
- The book states that Josie Packard's autopsy was performed on March 11, 1989. However, when going by how many days pass in the show by the time of her death, Josie would have died around March 22, 1989.
- As a result, this places Josie's death before that of Leland Palmer and Douglas Milford, the latter of which appears to be unchanged (the former is not mentioned in the book). This is sequentially incorrect in terms of the series.
- Douglas bought the Twin Peaks Gazette in 1969 and published a favorable article on his brother's fifth mayor candidacy. But Episode 17 states that Douglas wrote an unfavorable article for the first candidacy of his brother in 1962 although he was unopposed.
- In the book, Lawrence Jacoby had moved to Hawaii by March 19, 1989, writing his final notes about Laura and had his license revoked on March 26. However, Jacoby appears to still be practicing psychiatry in Twin Peaks in the final episodes, which take place after this date.
- In Hawk's journal "The Ballad of Big Ed and Norma and Nadine," there is a photo of Ed and Norma captioned "Big Ed and Norma at the RR." However, the photo is actually the two at the Roadhouse; a production still from the Pilot episode.
- The book states Briggs to be the only officer in the military facility of Twin Peaks. But Episode 19 shows USAF Colonel Calvin Reilly to be a superior officer who is into the loop with Listening Post Alpha activities.
- Reilly may have been a contact of Milford not stationed in Twin Peaks.
- The book states that the Great Northern opened in 1928 and Ben Horne was born in 1940. But Episode 18 shows a footage of Ben at the Great Northern groundbreaking. Similarly, the Access Guide states the Hotel groundbreaking to be in 1927 and using the same 1940 birthdate for Ben.
- The series and film state Deer Meadow to be in the southwest corner of Washington, but the book states it is one county west of Twin Peaks.
- The book states the Briggs received the "Cooper, Cooper, Cooper" message after Cooper solved Laura's murder, while in the series, it was during the investigation.
- The message might have been detected on two different occasions.
- The book states that Douglas' wedding occured on the same night Briggs disappeared but this was not the case in the series.
- Briggs indicates that when he returned after his disappearance, he appeared in the same spot in the woods where he left; he then ran home. In the series he appears in a flash of light in his living room.
With the Secret Diary of Laura Palmer Edit
- According to The Secret Diary of Laura Palmer, the Log Lady's husband died by having fallen face-first into hot coals and burning to death. The Secret History of Twin Peaks states that Sam Lanterman fell into a ravine during a fire.
- In The Secret History of Twin Peaks, Jacoby states that Laura began seeing him six months before her death, when The Secret Diary of Laura Palmer states that she began seeing him over a year prior.
With Access Guide to the Town Edit
- In the Access Guide, the football team photo seems to show enough players for a regular eleven-player team. But in the Secret History, the plaque and description shows a seven-player squad.
- The Guide states that coach Bobo Hobson was never caught on camera, fearing that it would take his soul but the dossier has a picture of him in a Twin Peaks Gazette article.
- It could be a mistake by the newspaper writer or maybe the coach was not aware of the picture being taken
- In the Access Guide, Harry team number is #10, Ed is #60, Hank is #81 and Stan Lillas is #80 but in the dossier, Harry is #45, Ed is #65 and Hank is #80.
- The Access Guide states the Martells arrived in Twin Peaks after the Packards, but the Secret History states the opposite.
- The Guide is produced by Richard Saul Wurman who is a good friend of Andrew Packard, thus he may have written it this way to favor his friend's family.
- In the Secret History, Pete's father is named Ersel, whose father is named Zebulon. But in the Access Guide, Pete's father is named Nealith, whose father is named Rudolph.
- In the Access Guide, Pete's father is the one to sell the Martell Mill to the Packards one week before dying of indigestion. In the Secret History, it is Pete's grandfather selling to Andrew's father on his deathbed.
- In the Access Guide, Andrew and Catherine's father is named Ezekial. In the Secret History, his name is Thomas.
- In the Access Guide, Harry is stated to be the son of a mill worker named Boyd Truman. In the Secret History, it is said that he is the son of sheriff Frederick Truman.
- In the Access Guide, Hawk is said to be the son of a Zuni shaman. In the Secret History, he is stated to be the full-blooded Nez Perce son of a mill worker.
- In the Access Guide, Frank and Jerry are not seen in the roster of the Twin Peaks High Steeplejacks football team of 1968 and the student manager is Herb Fredrick instead of Ben.
- In the Access Guide, the 1968 Steeplejacks never lost a game, including the last one against the Kettle Falls Cougars. In the Secret History, the 1968 Lumberjacks lost in their final game which was against the Kettle Falls Cougars.
- This list is incomplete
The audiobook edition features voices actors from the TV show reprising their or other roles as well as actors original to the franchise. No official credits of who plays what parts is known to be released. The following list includes all the actors and some of the audio characters portrayed:
- David Patrick Kelly as Deputy Director Gordon Cole / Major James Neely / Kenneth Arnold / Paul Lantz
- Annie Wersching as Special Agent Tamara Preston
- Michael Horse as Chief Joseph / Deputy Tommy 'Hawk' Hill
- Robert Knepper as Douglas Milford
- Russ Tamblyn as Dr. Lawrence Jacoby / Robert Jacoby
- Mark Frost as Dr. Dan Hayward / Dr. Will Hayward / Cyril Pons
- Amy Shiels as Mrs. Paul Lantz / Norma Jennings / Audrey Horne / Margaret Lanterman
- Mat Hostetler as Andrew Packard
- James Morrison as The Archivist
- Len Cariou as Thomas Jefferson / Richard Nixon
- Chris Mulkey as Hank Jennings
- Arthur Bishop
- Ari Fliakos
- Kyle MacLachlan as Special Agent Dale Cooper
A teaser video for the book was released on July 27, 2016.
It shows the hands of an FBI Special Agent opening the contents of a package from Gordon Cole, who is now the Deputy Director of the FBI. It is postmarked August 3, 2016. The following elements are then shown:
- A 1903 Edward S. Curtis photo of Chief Joseph
- Handwritten notes from someone searching for a mine with a man called Denver Bob
- A cup of coffee
- A receipt for a 1947 Buick Roadmaster, sold to Douglas Milford by a salesman named Bob J. Hart. In the trailer, the paper looks old and withered but in the book this 70 years old document seems in pristine condition.
- 2 sheets of paper pertaining to Kenneth Arnold's UFO sighting in July 1947
- A slice of cherry pie
- A 3rd sheet of paper pertaining to Kenneth Arnold's UFO sighting in July 1947
- A September 1947 physician's report concerning Margaret "Maggie" Coulson. It is interesting to note that the mark shown is the 3 triangles pointing at the centre marking that appears on Major Briggs' neck, not the one of two mountains that Margaret shows Cooper on the back of her knee. In the finished book the marking is changed to the way Cooper redraws the Major's markings on the chalkboard with the three triangles pointing upwards.
- Douglas Milford's United States Air Force enlistment form from December 8, 1941.
- A Hollywood postcard from Norma to her parents, dated April 17, 1969. The teaser's stamp is the - US10¢ PRESERVE THE ENVIRONMENT stamp issued on April 18, 1974 while the one in the finished book is the FIRST MAN ON THE MOON stamp issued on September 9, 1969.
- A log, possibly from the Log Lady.
- A memorandum from Cole to the special agent, whose name is redacted. It says that the contents are from Cooper's investigation in Twin Peaks and may be related to a current case the agent has been assigned to, and that the identity of the person who compiled it must be discovered.
Another teaser was posted to the account on September 20, containing the Chief Joseph quote, "I will go now to the place of smoke by the great falls and twin mountains to seek the aid of the Great Spirit Chief in this time of need."
A third teaser was posted on September 27, with another Jack Parsons quote: "I've often felt there were spirits in this wood..." with images of Nadine Hurley, the Log Lady, and Lawrence Jacoby flashing in the background.
Behind the scenes Edit
Frost wrote the novel following his and David Lynch's submission of the initial nine-episode script for the limited series, during production on the series itself. Lynch reportedly has not read the novel.
- ↑ Twin Peaks The Return: A Season Three Podcast - An interview with Mark Frost
- ↑ Tweet from Mark Frost on 19 October 2016
- ↑ James Morrison interview with Twin Peaks Unwrapped podcast #85
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kinf5ApBjmg&ab_channel=FlatironBooks
- ↑ https://twitter.com/Flatironbooks/status/775724278356537346
- ↑ https://twitter.com/Flatironbooks/status/778274718495498242
- ↑ https://twitter.com/Flatironbooks/status/780805087186878464
- ↑ https://twitter.com/TwinPeaksArchve/status/791340021282328577
- ↑ 
- ↑ Mark Frost interview with Twin Peaks Unwrapped #72
- ↑ Sabrina Sutherland's Reddit AMA